Strategy question
How would you position Devin (autonomous engineer) vs. Windsurf (AI IDE) within the same company?
- Cognition
- Strategy
- Hard
Practice this question out loud. An AI interviewer asks it, follows up like a real interviewer would, and scores your answer. Type or speak.
Start a mock interview on this question · Mock interview from a job description
What this question tests
Portfolio strategy: positioning two products from the same company so they complement rather than cannibalize each other.
How to approach it
- Clarify the two products: Devin, a fairly autonomous engineer that takes a task and works independently, and Windsurf, an IDE where a human drives with AI assistance.
- Segment by workflow: Windsurf fits tasks needing tight human judgment (design decisions, ambiguous requirements); Devin fits well-scoped, repetitive tasks (bug fixes, migrations, test writing).
- Position Windsurf as the daily driver for active development and Devin as a delegate for backlog and maintenance work that would otherwise not get done.
- Avoid pricing or messaging that makes users choose one exclusively, instead designing a handoff so a Windsurf user can delegate a ticket to Devin from within the IDE.
- Prevent internal cannibalization by measuring incremental value: does Devin usage grow the total engineering throughput, not just shift work from Windsurf.
- Define success as combined seat expansion across both products within an account, not just standalone growth.
What a strong answer includes
- Draws a clear line by task type (autonomous-suited vs. human-in-the-loop) rather than by user seniority or company size.
- Proposes a concrete integration point, like delegating a ticket from Windsurf directly to Devin, turning two products into one workflow.
- Defines cannibalization risk explicitly and proposes a metric (incremental throughput) to detect it.
- Shows awareness that this is a real, live positioning challenge for Cognition after the Windsurf acquisition.
- Recommends account-level expansion as the combined success metric.
Common mistakes
- Positioning them as direct substitutes with no integration story.
- Ignoring the real cannibalization risk between two products in the same company.
Likely follow-up questions
- How would you price the two products relative to each other?
- How would you build the handoff between Windsurf and Devin?
- How would you know if cannibalization was actually happening?
More strategy questions
- How would you decide which engineering tasks to route to Devin vs. a human?Cognition · Strategy · Medium
- After acquiring Windsurf, how would you integrate the two products without confusing users?Cognition · Strategy · Hard
- How would you price an autonomous engineer: per task, per seat, or outcome-based?Cognition · Strategy · Hard
- Google Keep is a free product to save, share notes etc. How would you make it a subscription product & monetize it?Google · Strategy · Hard
- How would you launch (roll out) Amazon Go?Amazon · Strategy · Hard
- With an unlimited network bandwidth what would you build?Google · Strategy · Hard
More questions from Cognition
Learn the skill behind it
Chapters of the AI PM course that teach what this question tests.
- Chapter 4: Discovery and strategy for AI products
- Chapter 9: Prove it paid off: outcomes, economics, and pricing
- Chapter 14: Get the job: the AI PM interview loop