See pricing
Advice Line with Seth Berkowitz of Insomnia Cookies
How I Built This with Guy RazGrowth

Advice Line with Seth Berkowitz of Insomnia Cookies

This Advice Line episode is a sharp lesson in customer-led growth. Seth Berkowitz keeps pulling founders away from broad marketing plans and back to the same questions: which product already wins, in what context, and with whom?

October 23, 2026 · 44 min listen · 14 min read · Seth Berkowitz
0:00
–:––

Context

This Advice Line episode is built around three founder problems that also show up in product work all the time: what to do after a major channel breaks, how to educate the market when the product category is unfamiliar, and how to market when the buyer is not the user. Seth Berkowitz, founder and CEO of Insomnia Cookies, answers from the perspective of someone scaling from roughly 393 bakeries toward an ambition of 1,800 while still resisting franchising. For PMs, the value is less about cookies and more about the operating logic underneath: focus on the smallest proven wedge, learn from real behavior instead of broad assumptions, and only scale once demand is clearly earned.

The Big Idea

Growth should be earned from visible customer pull, not forced through broader spend, broader assortment, or faster expansion. When the signal is weak, the answer is usually not more marketing. It is tighter focus on the product, occasion, and user that already work.

Across all three founder calls, Seth keeps returning to the same idea. Find the place where the product already makes intuitive sense, learn from that use case in detail, and scale only after customers themselves make the next step obvious.

Key Insights

Earn growth before scaling

Seth's growth philosophy is simple: expansion is something a business earns.

  • He says businesses earn the right to grow when they have real consumer love.
  • He contrasted that with a "grow first and see" mindset. He acknowledged that this sometimes works, but said it is not how he operates.
  • At Insomnia Cookies, he pointed to opening too many stores too quickly in some markets. In hindsight, he said closer attention to brand awareness metrics in each geography would have shown that demand was not as deep as expected.

For PMs, this is a strong reminder that distribution, spend, and roadmap breadth should follow evidence of pull. If awareness, activation, repeat use, or local demand is still shallow, scaling often hides weak product-market fit instead of fixing it.

Narrow to winning occasions

Both Seth and Guy pushed the first caller away from a broad catalog and toward the few products already proven to work.

  • Kahindo's brand had sales of $268K in 2023, then fell to $50K after losing key wholesale accounts.
  • Instead of trying to revive everything at once, Guy focused on the founder's own evidence: the three to five bestselling pieces and the occasions where customers actually wore them.
  • The useful question was not "how do I market the brand?" It was "which items already win, who buys them, and for what event?"

This matters for PMs because teams often react to a setback by widening the surface area. The better move is usually the opposite. Start with the features, user segment, or use cases that already show strong pull, then rebuild from there.

Education changes channel choice

The sauna hat business made a key point about category creation: some products are hard to sell through abstract digital messaging alone.

  • Sauna hats solve a real problem, but many people do not even know the problem exists.
  • Tara said most early sales came in person, often because she wore the hat herself and people asked about it.
  • Seth immediately focused on the education gap. If a product needs explanation before it sounds useful, then channels like Meta or Google ads may be weaker than places where people can see, ask, and try.
  • Tara also said the product has about 85% margin, which makes sampling, gifting, or low-cost seeding more viable than it would be for a low-margin product.

For PMs, this is a channel-product fit lesson. If the product's value becomes obvious only inside the real usage moment, then the learning loop should happen there too.

Design for the visible user

The third caller had discovered that many buyers were mothers and grandmothers, while the actual users were college students. Seth's answer was clear: center the user who carries the brand in public.

  • Desden sells licensed college bags and accessories for 90 universities.
  • Seth said the student is still the bullseye because the student creates the product's social currency.
  • His reasoning was that if the student loves the product, posts it, and wants to be seen with it, then the purchase path from gift giver becomes much easier.
  • He treated the payer as important, but secondary to the person whose identity and behavior shape demand.

This is directly relevant to PMs working on B2B, family, education, or gifting products. When buyer and user differ, do not assume they deserve equal weighting. Usually one of them determines adoption, word of mouth, and long-term value more than the other.

Physical context beats abstraction

A surprising through line in the episode is how often the best advice was to get closer to the environment where the product is actually used.

  • Kahindo was encouraged toward pop-ups, trunk shows, and boutiques where customers can touch the fabrics and hear the story.
  • Tara was encouraged toward spas, wellness clubs, hotel gift bags, and corporate gifting, all places where sauna use is already happening.
  • Carol described pop-ups at game weekends and ambassador programs on campuses, which Seth saw as a strong way to grow relevance with students.

For PMs, this is a reminder that user understanding gets sharper when the team goes to the setting where the decision happens. Surveys and dashboards help, but they rarely replace seeing the behavior in context.

Mental Models & Frameworks

Earned growth test

A simple growth test implied throughout the episode:

  • Signal: is there visible customer pull, such as awareness, repeat buying, strong word of mouth, or strong sell-through in a specific market?
  • Decision: if yes, expand faster. If no, tighten the offer before adding spend or scale.
  • Evidence source: Seth specifically mentioned watching brand awareness metrics by geography instead of assuming a market was deeper than it was.

Use this when deciding whether to scale a feature, channel, market, or retail footprint. It helps prevent the common mistake of treating distribution as the cure for weak demand.

Core wedge expansion

Seth described his own operating lesson in product terms: reduce the SKU set to the core, make that winning offer obvious, then build platforms around it later.

  • He said Insomnia had tried many adjacent items over time, including frozen yogurt and cupcakes.
  • His conclusion was that what won was reducing the SKUs down to the core.
  • Only after that core became well known did expansion make sense.

This is a useful PM framework for any product line. Before adding breadth, ask whether the core use case is already strong enough to support it.

Buyer user influencer map

The Desden discussion suggests a practical segmentation model for products with indirect purchasing.

  • User: the person who wears, uses, or publicly signals the product.
  • Buyer: the person who pays.
  • Influencer: the person who shapes the buyer's choice, often through social proof, requests, or visible excitement.

In Desden's case, the student was both the user and the influencer, even when a parent or grandparent paid. Use this map when messaging feels split across audiences. It helps clarify whose needs should drive product design and whose needs should drive conversion copy.

Teach inside the use case

When a product needs education, do not separate the explanation from the moment of use.

  • Let people see the product in the real environment.
  • Make it easy for them to ask questions in that moment.
  • Capture what they say back, because the objections and surprises become product and messaging input.

The sauna hat example made this clear. The product clicked fastest when someone saw it worn during a sauna session, not when reading a cold online description.

Decision Principles

Principle: Prove wedge first

  • When: a team is deciding whether to spend more on acquisition or launch a wider assortment.
  • Why: the first caller's best move was not broader advertising. It was deeper evidence around the few dresses and occasions already working.

Principle: Market to usage

  • When: one person pays but another person uses the product.
  • Why: Seth argued that the end user creates relevance and social proof. If the user does not care, the buyer's intent matters much less over time.

Principle: Spend where context teaches

  • When: a product's value proposition sounds strange until someone sees it in action.
  • Why: the sauna hat discussion showed that some products need live education. In that case, product-context fit matters more than pure ad reach.

Trade-offs & Nuance

Control versus expansion speed

Insomnia Cookies could likely expand faster through franchising, but Seth still resists it.

  • He said the business is operationally complex: late night, delivery-heavy, seasonal, and multi-channel.
  • He also said direct control lets Insomnia test and roll out innovations without heavy pushback or coordination costs.
  • The trade-off is clear: franchising may increase speed, but operating stores directly protects quality and innovation velocity.

For PMs, this is the classic trade-off between local autonomy and centralized control. Faster distribution can come with slower product learning.

Premium positioning versus trial

Tara's hats are premium, stylish, and roughly $60, which supports the brand. But premium pricing can also slow adoption for a product people do not yet understand.

  • Seth's instinct was that seeing and trying the product matters most.
  • That naturally raises questions about sampling, gifting, hotel partnerships, or lower-friction B2B distribution.
  • The tension is that broader trial can accelerate education, while cheaper or more promotional formats can weaken the premium signal.

PM lesson: when category education is the bottleneck, lowering learning cost can matter more than protecting every element of positioning.

Breadth versus brand clarity

The Kahindo conversation showed the risk of carrying too many directions at once during a reset.

  • A broad assortment may feel safer because it covers more possibilities.
  • In practice, it often weakens the message, spreads inventory and marketing effort, and makes it harder to know what is truly working.
  • Focusing on special occasion wear and the best-performing styles gave the brand a clearer story and a more measurable plan.

For PMs, clarity usually beats optionality when resources are thin.

Common Mistakes

Mistake: Broad ads too early

The first and second callers both asked some version of the same question: should they push harder on paid acquisition? The advice from Seth and Guy was mostly no, at least not yet.

  • Paid channels are tempting because they feel scalable.
  • They are weak when the team still does not know the sharpest audience, winning use case, or clearest message.
  • In those cases, ads amplify uncertainty rather than demand.

The better move is to use lower-scale channels that teach faster, then spend once the pattern is clearer.

Mistake: Too many weak SKUs

Seth explicitly tied his own learning at Insomnia to simplifying the assortment.

  • Too many products make the brand harder to understand.
  • They also make it harder to know which product is actually earning demand.
  • During a reset, the few proven winners usually deserve almost all the attention.

Mistake: Targeting the wrong persona

Carol's case is a good warning for teams that confuse the payer with the strategic customer.

  • A parent may transact once.
  • A student may create ongoing demand through visibility, taste, and social sharing.
  • If the product and brand are optimized for the payer alone, they can drift away from the person who actually gives the product cultural relevance.

Practical Application

Map your proven winners

For the next product review, make a short table with four columns:

  • the top three to five products or features by revenue or adoption
  • the user segment that chooses each one most often
  • the occasion or job that triggered the choice
  • the evidence you have, such as repeat rate, sell-through, return rate, or tagged social posts

This forces the team to build from proven demand instead of vague opportunity.

Collect occasion-level evidence

Do what Guy pushed Kahindo to do. Go beyond "who bought" and learn why this specific moment needed this product.

  • Add post-purchase questions about the event, trigger, or setting.
  • Review tagged photos and support conversations for language customers use naturally.
  • Bring the answers back into merchandising, copy, roadmap, and channel decisions.

Occasion-level evidence is often what turns broad segmentation into a usable strategy.

Test products in context

If a product needs explanation, run tests where the use case is already happening.

  • Put the product in pop-ups, partner locations, events, or ambassador programs.
  • Watch which questions come up before purchase.
  • Track whether in-context exposure lifts conversion more than cold digital traffic.

This is especially useful for new behaviors, premium categories, or products that look unusual until someone experiences them.

Separate buyer from user

In every funnel review, ask whether the same person is paying, using, and influencing the purchase.

  • If those roles differ, instrument them separately.
  • Collect buyer identity and user identity when possible.
  • Tailor product decisions to the person who drives adoption, and tailor messaging to the person who completes payment.

This prevents teams from building for the easiest person to survey instead of the person who matters most.

Set earned-growth gates

Before approving broader rollout, define the signals that would prove the business has earned the right to scale.

Examples from this episode's logic include:

  • local brand awareness reaching a defined threshold
  • strong sell-through in a boutique or campus pilot
  • repeat purchase or gifting behavior
  • low return rates on the few hero products

A growth gate turns "I think this is working" into a clearer decision rule.

Questions to Consider

  • Which product, feature, or customer segment in your roadmap is still too broad, and what would happen if you narrowed it to the three to five winning use cases with the strongest evidence?
  • Where is your team relying on paid acquisition even though the product still needs live explanation, hands-on trial, or social proof inside the real usage context?
  • If one person pays and another person uses your product, which of those people actually creates demand through behavior, identity, or word of mouth?
  • What specific signals, such as local awareness, repeat use, sell-through, or low returns, would prove that your product has truly earned the right to scale?

Bottom Line

Seth Berkowitz's advice is remarkably consistent across very different businesses: tighten focus before you widen reach. Find the product, user, and occasion that already work, learn from real behavior in the setting where the product is used, and only then scale spend, assortment, or expansion.

Case Studies Mentioned

Kahindo's post-wholesale reset

Kahindo built an African-rooted fashion brand and at one point reached $268K in annual sales, but after losing key wholesale accounts the business dropped to $50K. The advice was not to chase broad acquisition immediately. It was to pivot around the best-performing special occasion pieces, understand exactly who buys them and why, and rebuild with tighter focus before returning to broader wholesale.

Sauna hats need live proof

Sauna Societe sells premium sauna hats, a product that many consumers do not yet understand. Tara said most early sales came from wearing the hat herself, talking to people in person, and showing up at wellness events. The lesson is that when the product category needs education, the best channel is often the place where the behavior already exists.

Desden's buyer-user split

Desden sells officially licensed collegiate bags and accessories and has licenses with 90 universities. The founder discovered that many purchases came from mothers and grandmothers, while the actual users were students. Seth's advice was to keep the student at the center because the student creates the brand's public relevance, even when someone else pays.

Insomnia's no-franchise choice

Insomnia Cookies has grown to roughly 393 bakeries and wants to reach 1,800, but Seth still avoids traditional franchising. His reasoning is that the model is operationally complex and that direct operation protects both quality and the ability to test and roll out new ideas quickly. The broader lesson is that faster scale is not always worth the loss of control.

People to Follow

Seth Berkowitz

Seth Berkowitz is the founder and CEO of Insomnia Cookies. He is useful to follow for practical thinking on retail expansion, operating discipline, product focus, and the difference between scaling because a business can versus scaling because it has actually earned the right.

Notable Quotes

"I believe you earn growth. I think you earn the right to grow." (Seth Berkowitz)

"Consumer love gives you license, right?" (Seth Berkowitz)

"The consumer is the end user regardless of who paid for it always, right?" (Seth Berkowitz)

"Follow what the consumer is telling you, right? They are the answer to every question, right?" (Seth Berkowitz)

AI PM course

Everyone hears the same episodes.
Few can do what they describe.

Start for free