See pricing
From underdogs to disruptors: how Tubi and e.l.f. built a different game
Masters of ScaleStrategy

From underdogs to disruptors: how Tubi and e.l.f. built a different game

One CEO livestream on TikTok put a planned product on the market in six months instead of 12 to 18, and a Super Bowl audit found less than 1% of ads spoke to half the viewers. Tubi's Anjali Sud and e.l.f.'s Kory Marchisotto show how underdog brands win by refusing to play the leader's game.

November 10, 2026 · 26 min listen · 14 min read · Anjali Sud, Kory Marchisotto
0:00
–:––

Context

This episode is a live conversation from the Masters of Scale Summit in San Francisco, hosted by Bob Safian on Rapid Response. The guests are Anjali Sud, then CEO of the free streaming service Tubi, and Kory Marchisotto, president of the affordable beauty company e.l.f. Beauty. Both took brands that people once saw as downmarket and made them category disruptors: Tubi has more than 110 million monthly active users, and e.l.f. has grown for 30 consecutive quarters. Two weeks after the recording, Sud announced she was becoming CEO of SiriusXM. For PMs, the episode is a compact lesson in positioning a challenger product, finding underserved users, and keeping a direct feedback loop with customers as a company grows.

The Big Idea

An underdog wins by finding the customers incumbents overlook and building a different game for them, not by competing on the leader's terms.

Marchisotto lays this out as a four-part blueprint, and both companies back it with results: a free product proving it is not low quality, Super Bowl ads aimed at an audience other advertisers ignored, and direct livestreams that let customers steer the roadmap.

Key Insights

Free products fight a quality stigma

Sud says consumers assume that if something is free, there is a catch: the content must be low quality or the experience must be bad. That assumption was Tubi's main battle, even after more than a decade of offering free streaming.

  • Why it helped: she liked that Tubi was underestimated, because the product was actually good.
  • The lever: if anyone who tried it would enjoy it, the job is to get people to try it, not to rebuild the product.
  • The discipline: the key, in her words, is never losing focus on that product quality and staying committed to it.

For a PM on a free or low-priced product, this means perception is a separate problem from quality, and it needs its own plan.

Don't play the incumbent's game

Marchisotto points out that both companies compete in industries with huge, long-established leaders. e.l.f.'s rival L'Oréal is, in her words, a $45 billion company. Her stance is that a challenger cannot win on the incumbent's terms, so it should find a new way, change the conversation, and build a different game. The host framed e.l.f.'s position as prestige quality at drugstore prices, in a beauty market defined by premium pricing and exclusivity. Marchisotto reframes that as making the inaccessible accessible, which she says is exactly what Tubi does too.

Super Bowl had unserved viewers

e.l.f. treated the Super Bowl as a white-space problem, not a branding splurge.

  • The game draws about 120 million viewers, and women are about 50% of that audience.
  • e.l.f. studied every commercial and found less than 1% were talking to women.
  • No beauty brand had ever advertised in that slot before.
  • Its first ad put a 60-year-old woman, Jennifer Coolidge, at the center, and Marchisotto says every metric jumped, including unaided awareness and likeability.
  • Because that first ad worked so well, e.l.f. came back the next year with Judge Judy, an 80-year-old woman.

The lesson for PMs is that a "crowded" channel can still hide a large, ignored segment, and you only find it by auditing who the existing players actually address.

Big moments can prove the product

Asked whether the Super Bowl is a way to reach scale or to demonstrate it, Sud says it was both for Tubi. Two years before this recording, Tubi streamed the Super Bowl for free, in partnership with Fox Sports. She says it was the most streamed Super Bowl in history, offering millions of Americans free access in 4K with the lowest latency. The point was to show that premium entertainment does not need a huge price tag. For a challenger product, a high-profile moment works best when it directly disproves the doubt people have about it, here the belief that free means worse.

Zero distance speeds up the roadmap

Marchisotto's term zero distance means removing the gap between leadership and customers, using any place you can livestream. She argues that in many companies the C-suite sits in an ivory tower and leaves serving the consumer to everyone else.

  • The logic: instead of brainstorming in a room about what consumers want, ask them directly.
  • The proof: e.l.f. CEO Tarang Amin's first TikTok Live drew 15,000 people, who loudly demanded bronzing drops that were still in the pipeline.
  • The outcome: Amin left the livestream, went to the innovation team, and the product reached market in six months instead of the planned 12 to 18 months later.

The PM takeaway is that unfiltered, high-volume customer signal heard by a decision-maker can reorder a roadmap faster than any internal prioritization meeting.

Ask customers what else they want

Zero distance also widened what e.l.f. offers beyond product. When e.l.f. asked its community what they wanted to hear from the brand, the top answer was career advice, and the second was financial literacy. Marchisotto put CFO Mandy Fields on a Twitch livestream to teach financial literacy, and 110,000 people showed up. Her conclusion is that e.l.f. is no longer just a beauty brand to these customers but a trusted friend. For PMs, asking users what they want from the relationship, not just from the product, can reveal adjacent value that no feature request would surface.

Turn fans into creators

Sud says Tubi routinely greenlights shows and movies based on what fans talk about. The bigger shift is giving fans a voice as creators. Through a TikTok partnership called the Creatorverse, Tubi works with creators, who constantly make content based on what their own fans want.

  • TikTok creator Noah Beck had never made a movie before.
  • He became a star producer of a Tubi original franchise called Sideline, which reached 20 million views.
  • Tubi did no marketing for it; fans clipped scenes and shared them.
  • Beck has since gone on to star in Baywatch.

Sud describes the link between the creator economy and Hollywood as a bridge, not a battle. For a PM, creators who already know what their audience wants are a ready-made source of product and distribution.

Stay a challenger inside a giant

Tubi is owned by Fox, and its offices sit on the Fox lot. Sud says Tubi still operates like a startup and feels like a challenger every day, even with over a billion dollars in revenue, profitability, and 110 million monthly users. The team fought hard to preserve that culture. At the same time, being part of Fox gave Tubi access a pure startup would lack: the free Super Bowl stream with Fox Sports, World Cup matches, and related documentary content about the players. A PM inside a large company can use the parent's assets without adopting its slower habits.

Mental Models & Frameworks

The four-part underdog blueprint

Marchisotto offered this as her breakdown of how businesses that serve the underserved win.

  1. See the overlooked consumer: find the people everybody else misses. She says they "roar with courage" once a brand finds them.
  2. Challenge conventions: refuse to play the incumbent's game, and change the conversation instead.
  3. Scale in the white space: identify what these people desire and what is available to them, then build in the gap between the two.
  4. Open the door for others: once you prove there is another path, others follow.

The Super Bowl campaign is her worked example: women were half the audience (step 1), no beauty brand had advertised there (step 2), and the ad was built around older women to stand out (step 3).

Desire minus availability

Inside the blueprint's third step is a simple test for white space: list what a target group actually desires, list what is currently available to them, and the gap between those two lists is where to build. It is useful for PMs sizing an opportunity, because it starts from an underserved group rather than from a competitor's feature list.

Ask what business you're in

When asked why a beauty brand would take on corporate boards, Marchisotto said the question is what business you are really in. e.l.f.'s answer is liberating access: to the best of beauty, to equity (every e.l.f. employee, down to coordinators and the front desk, is a shareholder), and to the boardroom. Defining the business at that level is what lets a brand move into new areas without looking off-brand.

Bold disruptor with a kind heart

e.l.f. describes itself as "bold disruptors with a kind heart." Marchisotto argues that many companies have one trait or the other, but few have both, and she calls that intersection unicorn territory. She adds that knowing who you are attracts partners who are doing the same, which is how she says she connected with Sud.

Decision Principles

Principle: Audit a channel's audience first

  • When: deciding whether a big, expensive channel like a major ad slot is worth entering.
  • Why: e.l.f. found that less than 1% of Super Bowl ads addressed women, who were about half of 120 million viewers, so a channel that looked saturated was actually open.

Principle: Let the decision-maker hear customers

  • When: a feature or product is stuck behind a long internal timeline.
  • Why: after hearing 15,000 TikTok Live viewers demand bronzing drops, e.l.f.'s CEO pulled the launch forward to six months, a change internal meetings had not produced.

Principle: Double down on what works

  • When: a bold bet clearly beats expectations.
  • Why: after the Jennifer Coolidge ad moved every metric, e.l.f. repeated the same idea more boldly the next year with 80-year-old Judge Judy, instead of switching to a new concept.

Trade-offs & Nuance

Different, but not just different

Sud stresses that Tubi and e.l.f. approach their categories differently, but "not different just to be different." The difference has to serve the consumer and put them first. Provocative choices like a strange cowboy-hat Super Bowl spot work for Tubi because, as Sud puts it, its fans are eclectic and sometimes a little unhinged, and the brand reflects them. Unconventional for its own sake, without that grounding in the audience, would just be noise.

Startup culture versus parent assets

Being inside Fox could have made Tubi feel like a studio division. Sud says it has not, but that keeping the challenger feel took real effort. The upside is access to Fox's sports rights and Hollywood relationships, which made the free Super Bowl stream possible. The tension is that a PM has to protect the team's speed while still using the parent's scale.

Representation versus measurable impact

Sud says the part of e.l.f.'s boardroom message that stood out to her is moving the conversation past representation to impact. Marchisotto backs that with e.l.f.'s 30 consecutive quarters of growth and says a variety of perspectives changes business outcomes. This is the guests' claim, linking board diversity to e.l.f.'s growth; the episode does not present a controlled comparison.

Practical Application

Audit who competitors ignore

  • Do: pick the main channel or category you compete in and review every competitor's messaging, as e.l.f. did with every Super Bowl ad.
  • Then: note which large user groups almost nobody is addressing.
  • Why it works: e.l.f. found women were about half of the Super Bowl audience but the focus of less than 1% of ads, an opening that only a full audit revealed.

Put a leader on a livestream

Schedule a live session where a senior decision-maker, not only a community manager, answers customers directly. Prepare the team to act on what comes up. At e.l.f., the CEO's first TikTok Live surfaced demand that pulled a product launch from 12 to 18 months out down to six months.

Ask users about the relationship

Run a short survey or live poll asking customers what they want to hear or learn from your company, not which feature they want next. e.l.f. got career advice and financial literacy as the top answers, and a CFO-led financial literacy livestream drew 110,000 people.

Plan perception for free tiers

If your product is free or cheap, list the specific doubts users likely have, such as "free means low quality." Then design launches or moments that directly disprove them. Tubi used a free, 4K, low-latency Super Bowl stream to show that free streaming can be premium.

Partner with creators who know audiences

Find creators who already serve your target users and give them a way to build on your platform. Tubi's Sideline franchise, produced by first-time movie maker and TikTok creator Noah Beck, reached 20 million views with no paid marketing because fans clipped and shared it.

Questions to Consider

  • Which large user group in our category gets almost no attention from competitors, the way women got less than 1% of Super Bowl ads?
  • What doubt do people have about our product's price or positioning, such as "free means bad," and what launch would directly disprove it?
  • How many layers sit between our product leaders and unfiltered customer feedback, and what would happen if a leader heard 15,000 customers at once?
  • If we answered "what business are we really in?" at the level e.l.f. does ("liberating access"), what new areas would our product be allowed to enter?
  • Are we competing on the market leader's terms, or have we defined a game the leader cannot easily play?

Bottom Line

Tubi and e.l.f. grew from downmarket underdogs into disruptors by serving people incumbents overlooked and refusing to compete on the leaders' terms. They kept that edge by staying close to customers, through livestreams, fan-driven programming, and creators, so customer demand could shape the product directly.

Case Studies Mentioned

e.l.f. bronzing drops launch

On the CEO's first TikTok Live, 15,000 people showed up and pressed for bronzing drops, a product still in the pipeline. The CEO went straight to the innovation team, and e.l.f. launched it in six months instead of 12 to 18 months later. The lesson is that direct, live customer demand can justify reprioritizing a roadmap on the spot.

e.l.f.'s "So Many Dicks" campaign

About 10 quarters into her time at e.l.f., Marchisotto noticed the company's board was majority female and very diverse, and asked investor relations to compare it with all 3,700 publicly traded companies. e.l.f. was the only one that was majority female with over 40% diverse representation. Because the data was not readily available, the team entered 37,000 board member names into a database by hand. They found more men named Richard or Dick on boards than entire underrepresented groups, and a comment in a creative brainstorm became the campaign name. Instead of taking a victory lap, e.l.f. used the finding to push other boards to change, backed by its 30 consecutive quarters of growth.

Tubi's free Super Bowl stream

Tubi streamed the Super Bowl for free in partnership with its parent company's Fox Sports, in 4K with low latency. Sud says it was the most streamed Super Bowl in history. It served both as a way to reach fans and as proof that premium entertainment can be free.

Tubi's Sideline franchise

TikTok creator Noah Beck, who had never made a movie, became a star producer of the Tubi original franchise Sideline. It reached 20 million views without marketing, driven by fans clipping and sharing scenes. It shows how creators with existing audiences can carry both content and distribution.

People to Follow

Anjali Sud

Former CEO of Tubi, which she grew to more than 110 million monthly active users and over a billion dollars in revenue while profitable. Two weeks after this recording, she announced she was becoming CEO of SiriusXM. She has spent over a decade helping storytellers use technology to lower the barriers to making and distributing their work.

Kory Marchisotto

President of e.l.f. Beauty, which has grown for 30 consecutive quarters to about $2 billion in annual sales. She is behind e.l.f.'s Super Bowl strategy, its "zero distance" approach to livestreaming with customers, and the "So Many Dicks" boardroom campaign.

Notable Quotes

"I can't play your game. I'm not going to win at it." (Kory Marchisotto)

"Why am I going to sit in a room and brainstorm with a bunch of folks what the consumers want? Why not ask them directly?" (Kory Marchisotto)

"We as consumers tend to think if something is free, there's a catch." (Anjali Sud)

"This is not a beauty brand anymore. This is a trusted friend." (Kory Marchisotto)

AI PM course

Everyone hears the same episodes.
Few can do what they describe.

Start for free