Behavioral question
What do you do when you get a vague feature request?
- American Express
- Behavioral
- Easy
Practice this question out loud. An AI interviewer asks it, follows up like a real interviewer would, and scores your answer. Type or speak.
Start a mock interview on this question · Mock interview from a job description
What this question tests
Practical process for turning ambiguity into a scoped, actionable requirement.
How to approach it
- Start by asking who requested it and what underlying problem or goal they're trying to solve, not just the literal ask.
- Gather context: what triggered the request, like a customer complaint or a competitor comparison.
- Translate the vague ask into a specific user problem statement before considering any solution.
- Check feasibility and scope with engineering early, rather than committing to a timeline blind.
- Propose a scoped version back to the requester for confirmation before starting real work.
What a strong answer includes
- Leads with asking why, uncovering the underlying goal rather than accepting the vague request at face value.
- Distinguishes gathering context from jumping straight to a solution, showing discipline under ambiguity.
- Loops in engineering early for a feasibility gut check before committing to any scope or timeline.
- Closes the loop by confirming the scoped interpretation with the original requester before building.
Common mistakes
- Starting to build immediately based on a literal, unclarified reading of the request.
- Never circling back to confirm the interpreted scope with the original requester.
Likely follow-up questions
- What do you do if the requester is not available to clarify?
- How do you handle it if the underlying goal changes after you've started building?
More behavioral questions
- Have you ever disagreed with your Engineering counterparts? What did you do when a build decision was made that did not align with the original vision you had?American Express · Behavioral · Medium
- What is one career failure you faced? How did you deal with it?American Express · Behavioral · Medium
- Describe a time when you faced an obstacle during a build. How did you ensure you were still able to hit your milestones? Did you have to break down feature requests?American Express · Behavioral · Medium
- What is your product management approach? How do you set goals?American Express · Behavioral · Easy
- If the legal team reached to you with a difficult request, what is your method for tackling it?American Express · Behavioral · Easy
- What was the biggest challenge you experienced from working with banks? How did you go about convincing them?American Express · Behavioral · Easy
More questions from American Express
Learn the skill behind it
Chapters of the AI PM course that teach what this question tests.
- Chapter 13: Lead the room: staff moves, forward-deployed PM, and the portfolio
- Chapter 14: Get the job: the AI PM interview loop